When working sock knitting patterns, there are a lot of options. You can knit socks on double points, use the magic loop technique, or knit on two circular needles. You can knit one at a time, two at a time, or two at a time with one nested inside the other. There are as many choices in sock knitting as there are in sock yarn!

The heel is a part of your knit sock that takes a lot of wear, and is critical in the comfort and the fit of your sock.

To become a true sock expert we encourage you to try as many sock constructions as you can—and we're here to help you review some of the options! All of the methods we cover today were worked from the bottom up, as if you were working a toe-up sock. However, there are top-down equivalents for all of the techniques; a simple Internet search will turn up all sorts of options.

Afterthought Heel

afterthought heel

The afterthought heel allows you to knit the
whole sock as a tube, then work the heel afterward.

Pro: It makes knitting your sock super easy—whether you're working from the toe or from the cuff  90% of your sock will just be knitting without any shaping.

Con: It's not the most comfortable heel, and has a tendency to slip off the foot. A great tutorial from The Yarn Harlot on the afterthought heel, and another one from Knitting Up A Storm.

 

 

 

Traditional Heel Flap 

heel flap

A sock with a heel flap is the classic knit sock.
You can work a slip stitch pattern on the flap
to make it even more durable.

Pro: Fits well and it's easy to customize and work a pattern on the heel.

Con: If you're working with a self striping yarn the yarn will pool on the heel. Here's a great tutorial from Miriam Felton on creating a better fitting toe-up heel flap, and here's one from Knit Better Socks on how to work a top-down heel flap.

Short-Row Heel 

short row heel

The short row heel is a quick and easy heel that
doesn't require a gusset. That means it'll probably be faster to knit.
The fit is usually more comfortable than an afterthought heel.

Pro: It's fast and fairly simple to work, there are many variations so you're sure to find a technique that works for you.

Con: It tends to create holes in the heel, and is less sturdy than a heel flap. Here's a detailed tutorial on working a short row heel on a top-down sock from Laura Chau. Here's a no wrap version of the short row heel from Happy Knits.

Fleegle's Heel 

fleegle heel

Fleegle's heel is a combination of the
short-row heel and the traditional heel flap.

Pro: Fleegle's heel is more subtle in look than the heel flap and provides a heel without holes.

Con: Following the directions is not for the beginner knitter, we recommend knitting a more traditional sock before trying Fleegle's heel. Here is Fleegle's guide to her toe-up no-flap, no-hassle heel, and here's a guide to working the heel from the top-down by Knitters Brewing Co.

Fish Lips Kiss Heel 

fish lips kiss heel

The photo above is a pair of socks using the
Fish Lips Kiss Heel and Cascade Heritage Prints sock yarn.

Pro:  The Fish Lips Kiss Heel has no wraps to pick up and does not use the traditional heel flap and gusset, so it's an easier and quicker heel to complete. There's also no picking up stitches for a gusset, because there's no gusset! So simple. Get the Fish Lips pattern (it's just $1) and see what you think!

Con:  If you have a high arch, you still may need a heel flap to make your sock fit. Also, The Fish Lips Kiss Heel isn't quite as defined of a heel, so with some people may find it slips a bit. 

Now it's time to get knitting—pick out some sock yarn and a Free Pattern, and cast on!

If you like watching videos, here is a 10 minute tutorial I did on picking up perfect stitches for the afterthought heel.

P.S. We'd love to hear about your favorite sock heel! Leave a comment below and tell us which you prefer, or if there's a heel technique we forgot. 

Kelley Hobart
Kelley Hobart


20 Responses

Sandy
Sandy

October 05, 2016

Fish Lips Kiss Heel

kcjohnston
kcjohnston

October 05, 2016

I like use the short row shaping a lot but I have also had good success using a heel construction found in Cat Bordhi’s “Personal Footprints for Insouciant Sock Knitters.” You just have to be careful in closing your seam at the back or it will rub on the heel.

Ellene
Ellene

October 05, 2016

Couldn’t agree more.

cp
cp

October 05, 2016

The gusset on the fleegle heel has the increases going the wrong way. :P

My favorite heel was first described by Lumi in her blog as a version of the yoyo heel. It was later fleshed out by a lady on Ravelry and called the Fish Lips Kiss Heel. An excellent way to do a short row heel, eliminating holes.

Bonnie M
Bonnie M

October 05, 2016

Thank you for the pros and cons of each. Very helpful. But how about the fish lips heel?

Mari Luke
Mari Luke

October 05, 2016

Bonnie,
That’s another great heel. Maybe we need to do a part two? Cat Bordhi’s Sweet Tomato Heel is another great one that we haven’t covered yet.

CP
CP

October 05, 2016

You made the gusset on your fleegle heel on the wrong side. The increases should be made on the bottom half of the sock, not the top half. (same as a toe-up heel flap heel)

Also, the fleegle sock was my first sock pattern I followed and I found it very easy. Way easier than flap and short row heels I tried later. It was a great intro to sock construction.

The strong heel is the same heel, but worked top down.

elizaanne189
elizaanne189

October 05, 2016

Fish lips kiss heel is the way to go as far as I’m concerned!

jjcroknits
jjcroknits

October 05, 2016

Fish Lips Kiss Heel is my favorite!

Jeanie
Jeanie

October 05, 2016

Would love a part 2!

kira makes a Fleegle heel | kira makes blog
kira makes a Fleegle heel | kira makes blog

October 05, 2016

[…] later found this page “How to Choose Your Sock Heel” which compares a couple different heels, with images. I think I will continue to use the […]

Kitty Call
Kitty Call

October 05, 2016

I love the fish lips kiss heel..no holes and so far is very durable.

Elizabeth
Elizabeth

October 05, 2016

What about Wendy D Johnson’s heel with a difference? Where the gusset is on the bottom of your heel? Or the boot strap heel? Oh just do a part 2 and make us all very happy! :-)

Karin
Karin

October 05, 2016

I’ve been using the fish lips kiss heel lately, and love it. My very first heel was the fleegle heel, so not sure why it’s not recommended for beginner knitters (btw, my first pair of socks was my second knit project, after a shawl). I’ve also tried the heel flap, which I hated.

Last Week on the Web | Threadpanda
Last Week on the Web | Threadpanda

October 05, 2016

[…] finally, Alpaca Direct shares four different sock-heel constructions. There’s many more ways to make a sock heel, but this is a great place to start. Share your […]

Judy
Judy

October 05, 2016

German (or double stitch) short rows.

Rebecca
Rebecca

October 05, 2016

I’ve been making socks for 20+ years. The sturdiest is a flap heel in a heel stitch continued through the heel turning. I use wooly nylon to reinforce the flap. Then 1×1 ribbing under the foot until the gusset decreases are finished. The ribbing makes the sock hug the foot at the heel. This formula fits most of my family best. The one odd man out has a blocky ankle and prefers the short row, no wrap heel Percilla Gibson Roberts wrote up. Socks wear out at heels, the ball of the foot and the toes. All three can be forestalled by making sure the foot is long enough. Reknitting the foot or toe of a holey socks is much easier for me when a sock is made from the top down.

Rebecca
Rebecca

October 05, 2016

Absolutely. Fish Lips rule.

Autumn
Autumn

October 05, 2016

Is a fish lips kiss heel the same as a short row heel?

Pin Ups and Link Love: My Favourite Things This Week - Knitted Bliss
Pin Ups and Link Love: My Favourite Things This Week - Knitted Bliss

October 05, 2016

[…] Sock knitters, take note! Here is a mini guide on choosing your perfect knitted sock heel, for either toe up or cuff down. Pinterest link is here, and the original post is here. […]

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in Alpaca Direct Blog

Kelley's Favorite Free Knit Sweater Patterns
Kelley's Favorite Free Knit Sweater Patterns

by Meg Bateman January 02, 2022 1 min read

Do you feel lost when it comes to picking out your first knit sweater pattern? This week, Kelley shared her favorite sweater patterns during Technique Tuesday. These patterns all feature minimal seaming, have detailed instructions, and have lots of completed projects on Ravelry! 

 

Free Beginner Sweater Patterns to Try

Kelley has knit the Brick Sweater several times, and has decided to knit it again with all our Technique Tuesday viewers! Grab some worsted weight yarn and join us for this informal knit along. 

Read More
Christmas Gifts for Knitters & Loved Ones
Christmas Gifts for Knitters & Loved Ones

by Meg Bateman January 02, 2022 1 min read

Do you have a knitter in your life that you would love to give a gift to? Not only do knitters love receiving knitted items, but you can get them some essential knitting supplies and tools as well!
Read More
How to Use the Fix-A-Stitch
How to Use the Fix-A-Stitch

by Meg Bateman January 02, 2022 1 min read

Do you struggle with fixing your knitting mistakes or dropped stitches? Kelley loves the Fix-A-Stitch tools! They're uniquely made to make it very easy to quickly fix your knitting mistakes. Here, Kelley demonstrates how to use the Fix-A-Stitch to fix stockinette, purl stitches, and garter stitch using the Fix-A-Stitch tools. 
Read More